Our pet dogs aren’t going to stay in the yard without a little encouragement and training. There is too much out in that big wide world to tempt them away. The neighbours probably have dogs of their own that are fun to play with. Perhaps there are neighbourhood cats or squirrels to chase around. Sometimes that smell down the street is just too enticing.
When dogs are determined enough to leave the yard, and aren’t trained not to, they can run off and get into all sorts of trouble. This is why pet owners need to find the best wireless dog fence.
Best Wireless Dog Fence 2019: Short Summery
|Extreme Electric Dog Fence|
|PetSafe Stay & Play Wireless Fence|
|Petsafe Wireless Pet Containment System|
|PetControlHQ Wireless Combo Dog Fence|
|Sit Boo-boo Advanced Dog Fence|
Wireless Dog Fence vs In-ground Dog Fence
There are pros and cons to both of these options depending on your property and situation. Let’s take a closer look at both solutions to see which may be best for you.
Wireless dog fence:
Wireless electric dog fences are a little bit different. The basic principles are the same. Dogs still wear the same sort of collars with the same forms of correction. The difference is that the boundary comes from a circular zone with a transmitter in the centre.
In-ground dog fence:
In-ground invisible dog fences use a strong wire through the ground. The border marked out via this wire indicates the boundaries of the property. The transmitter sends a signal to the dog collar and corrects the dog as needed.
Top 6 Wireless Dog Fence Reviews
Below are some in-ground and wireless dog fence reviews about some of the very best options on the market right now. They come from a range of respected brands and have many important features. We have compiled some of the key points here to help you compare your options.
1. Extreme Dog Fence – Second Generation Edition
This extreme dog fence is a new and improved model that can cover an area of up to 25 acres (the previous version was only 10 acres). With this custom shape wireless dog fence you get a lot of product for your money.
It comes with updated electronics on the collars with 3 antenna and improved responses.There a 20 gauge wire with a protective jacket, digital transmitter and plenty of boundary flags.
2. PetSafe Stay & Play Wireless Fence – Best wireless fence
The next model in our PetSafe wireless fence reviews has a smaller circular range of just 0.75 acres. But, it does come with 50 training flags and a rechargeable, adjustable collar that extends from 6 to 23 inches. Like the version above, there are 5 levels of correction, as well as a tone-only training mode.
Moving onto the best wireless dog fence amazon offers, we have two PetSafe wireless dog fence products. This model lets users create a circular boundary up to 90 feet. This is smaller than the ones above, but enough for many suburban yards.
There are also 5 correction levels and a tone-only mode for training. The promise is that you can train your pet in just two weeks when used correctly. Look more features here.
4. PetControlHQ Wireless Combo Electric Dog Fence System
These powerful, vast systems are appealing to anyone looking for the best electric dog fence for large dogs. The strong collars and range of options mean that there is potential for all kinds of breeds. This model has 492ft of 20 gauge boundary wire, 50 training flags and a good collar.
This model is appealing to many pet owners because of the idea that it can auto adjust to the dog’s needs. This suggests a system that is able to customise itself and make things easier for the handler. The system contains 500ft of industrial grade copper wire and a transmitter.
As you can see from the pros and cons of the systems above, there are some important considerations to make when choosing the best wireless electric dog fence for your home. The main features of interest can be broken down into two main components. There are the features within the wireless system itself and then there are those within the collar.
Important features to look out for when focusing on the dog collar.
- The means of correction: The way that you correct the dog is important. Many of the best collars have a choice of vibrations and tones with a sliding scale on intensity. This means you can fine tune the product to your needs.
- The adjustable nature of the collar: The collar should also be adjustable to fit the neck of the dog with ease. If it is too tight then it could be a safety risk. Too loose and the dog may escape. Check the specifications before purchasing.
- The security: Security is important here in terms of both the clips on the collar and its durability. The best collars have a tough, waterproof housing so that dogs can play in water or be out in the rain.
- Battery life: Finally, read up on the battery life of these collars. Some systems last for weeks before they need to be recharged. Others may only last for a couple of days. Also, check to see how long it takes to recharge the collar.
Frequently asked questions
1. Are these products safe to use?
This is a big concern because of recent issues with shock collars and bans on some devices. There are different products with different options. It is possible to get models that are purely for vibration and tone. You can set these collars to a safe level. Remember that you only want to tell the dog they are doing something wrong. You don’t want to punish them for a mistake as they learn.
2. Can I use this on puppies?
This is a great question. The answer is yes, but we recommend that you are careful and monitor the dogs carefully. It always helps to train dogs early so they don’t learn bad habits. At the same time, you don’t want to put them at risk of distress. As long as the vibrations are minimal, the collar fits and the training is clear, you can use this on puppies over 6 months old.
3. Can I use this on any breed?
The answer here may depend on the product that you choose. Most of the best wireless dog fence systems will have adjustable collars. Generally, this is for small to large dogs, but you do need to measure your dog’s neck to be sure it will fit. As long as the collar fits and they understand the correction, it should work. Success has much more to do with the quality of the product and the training you provide than the breed of dog.
4. Is it true that I can’t park my car near the transmitter?
Unfortunately, this is the case for a lot of these products. These containment systems rely on a strong connection in a clear radius from the transmitter to the boundary. Metallic objects can disrupt that signal, which may potentially break the boundary or move it slightly. Cars are one such metallic object, so don’t place the transmitter close to the drive. Also, don’t place it near metal roofs or other structures.
5. How does my dog understand where the boundaries are?
There is more to this system than putting a collar on a dog, a transmitter in the yard and letting the animal run free. There are steps you need to take to show the dog where the boundary is and train them on how to use the system. We will talk about this a little more below.
Other Wireless Fence That Didn’t Make Our Shortlist
The market for pet containment systems is vast with lots of different brands trying to diversify their range. There is competition to create the best wireless dog fences, the best in-ground dog fences and all kinds of products in between. There are also hybrid systems and alternative options for indoor use. There are some products that have a good specification and function but weren’t quite good enough for our original shortlist. Then there are others that try to compete and fail. Below is a selection of these products to help you choose the best system for your pet.
Some of the other wireless dog fences that are currently on the market.
Starting with an old favourite in PetSafe, we have a small system with a acre boundary. The waterproof receiver collar is adjustable and suitable for animals over 5pounds – which is why it is sold as a model that has potential for cats as well as dogs. There are also training flags and 5 levels of static correction.
- Portable design
- Lots of training aids
- Great for smaller animals
- Issues with interference
- A lack of instructions
A benefit here is that this is built as a portable unit to take away when camping or to a summer home. It should be so easy to set up that you can alter the boundary and train dogs anywhere. There are also plenty of white flags to help dogs understand where they can and cannot go. As with all these wireless models, there is the risk of interference so be careful where you set this up, especially if a car is parked on the campsite. It also doesn’t come with many instructions, which suggests that this is best suited to owners that have experience with this sort of product.
This should mean a containment zone of up to 1.3 acres of land. The receiver has tone and vibration modes, is waterproof and is expandable so you can add other dogs as needed. There is 1000 feet of 20-gauge boundary wire and 100 flags. Visit SportDog official website to see more features.
- There are some great results that suggest reliability in the connection.
- There are plenty of different options in the collar to get the best response from the dog.
- Users also like the inclusion of the wire break alarm.
- Some are a little concerned by the size of the battery pack on the collar.
- There is a long installation process, especially when tried to add a lightning protector.
The company claims that this is the most-advanced collar available, but many would disagree with this statement. The idea is that the wi-fi in the smart station tracks the location of the dog and warns them when they stray too far. Therefore, there isn’t the same sort of invisible perimeter as we would use with the other wireless products.
- The use of smarter wi-fi to connect to the collar
- A good signal in the right conditions
- Easy to set up
- Too many unsuitable conditions that lead to interference
- Questions over the true range
This product has potential when the system is activated and there is no risk of interference, as long as the animals don’t stray too far. The collar actually looks pretty flimsy and there are the same issues of interference as you would expect with any wireless containment system. Some also say that the advertised maximum distance of 2.5 acres is inaccurate. Understandably, there are some questions over the high price tag when this “smart” system isn’t quite as smart as hoped for.
This product uses a series of different correction modes to help control dogs that get too close to the boundary. Users can set the static correction with different intensity levels and change the boundary between 25 and 550 yards. Dogs can wear the smart collar and receive correction when they stray too close to the edge. There is a progressive system from low to high intensity here. Dogs are warmed, then corrected further if they don’t move.
- The progressive correction system on the static
- The adjustable boundary on the transmitter
- The quality of the collar
- The risk of malfunctions on the higher settings
- The lack of training flags.
There are sure to be some buyers that will struggle with this form of correction. The high intensity and repeated static can seem a little intense and there is a potential risk of malfunctions. There are also no training flags in the kit to help dogs figure out where they can and cannot go.
This is a pretty middle-of-the-road product in terms of the functions and tech on offer. There is a transmitter that creates a radius up to 500ft so that dogs are free to roam – up until a point. Dogs wear a collar that offers just enough correction if they stray too far. There is also the promise that the battery in the collar will last for 3 days.
- The long battery life
- The long range on the system
- The ease of use
- Mixed responses from the dogs
- The collar isn’t completely waterproof
When the system works, the user are impressed with the response and the range on offer. They also say that it is pretty easy to install and the dogs picked it up fairly quickly. One issue here is that the collar is water-resistant, not waterproof. The company claims that dogs can get rain in the rain or under sprinklers, but it seems that you cant submerge the collar, as with other brands.
The main selling point with this model is the fact that it has a GPS system. This means that the device should be able to track the location of a dog within an 800-meter radius. The signal is sent to a strong waterproof collar that is adjustable to fit dogs up to 120lbs. The idea here is that this system is far more reliable for correction than a typical radio signal.
- The use of a GPS system for pet tracking
- The wider range of sensitivity levels in the collar
- The strong build
- A risk of interference in unsuitable conditions
- Questions over the radius
Other benefits here are the range of 7 sensitivity level in the static collar and the strong build. The biggest concern here is that there are too many unsuitable scenarios for such a “reliable” GPS system. They claim that this is ideal because there isn’t the same metal interference. Yet, there is a warning not to use this near the edge of a tall building, near thick tree cover or on days with dark clouds.
There are a lot of great sales claims about the design of this fence. There is the promise of an easy plug n play installation with the simple receiver and transmitter. There is an adjustable range on the boundary of up to 500ft and there are up to 100 sensitivity levels on the waterproof, adjustable collar. This all sounds as though users should get a great result from this system.
- A simple, user-friendly approach to the kit
- An impressive number of sensitivity levels
- Waterproof collar
- Inconsistencies with the beeping
- A lack of training flags
The simplicity of the product and the design of the collar are all great at the start. The collar is strong and waterproof and there isn’t much of an installation process. But, there are far too many complaints about the collar beeping when it shouldn’t. This all leads to a very confused dog that struggles with his boundary training. It also doesn’t help that the product doesn’t come with any training flags – which is a common feature with so many other kits.
The main difference with this product is that it is a 2-in-1 system designed for use with boundary training but also other forms of correction. Owners can set up the invisible circular perimeter as normal, with the transmitter correcting the animal if they stray too far. But, there is also the chance to use the remote control feature to correct dogs if they bark, dig or so something else that they shouldn’t.
- The two in one system for two different types of correction
- The different warning signals on the collar
- The adjustability of the waterproof collar
- Unreliable connections to the collar
- Flaws in the 2-dog system
The fence has a radius of 110m and vibrates, shocks or offers an audible deterrent. The collar is adjustable up to 25 inches and waterproof. One of the biggest problems is that the 2-dog system can’t always differentiate between the two animals. Therefore, if one makes a mistake or strays too far, the product may end up shocking both dogs instead. There are also inconsistencies in the responses.
The most important feature to mention about this product is that this is an indoor model. This may confuse some dog owners when they try to set this up outside and find their dog can’t really go anywhere. The idea is that it stops puppies from wandering into bedrooms and other areas where they can cause mischief. The coverage area is between 1 and 6 ft from the barrier. Place it by a bedroom door, put the collar on the dog and create that invisible boundary.
- The adjustable boundary from the transmitter
- The safety features for puppies
- The easy setup
- The static may be too gentle
- Some dogs do run through the zone and don’t learn
The collar is waterproof, light and as a low static correction system. An issue here is that it doesn’t work for all animals. Some determined dogs do learn that they can run through the 6ft zone, get a mild shock and it is worth it for their reward.
This is another indoor model to stop animals from jumping up onto couches, going near the stairs or generally being where they shouldn’t. The range on this model is much wider with a radius between 3.3 feet and 10 feet from the target. This should prove to be more effective as a deterrent. There is a warning tone when dogs approach the transmitter and then increased static if they don’t move away.
- A better range for an indoor model
- Progressive correction
- Reliable most of the time
- Results vary depending on the puppy
- There aren’t many settings for the intensity of the collar
This adjustable model has great potential for all kinds of breeds and puppies – as well as some cats. There aren’t too many problems with this option as it seems to be reliable enough for most owners needs. Some might argue that there could be more settings for intensity levels on the collar – as there are only three of them.
The main selling point with this collar is the idea that this is a simple wireless containment unit with a wider range than normal. This is meant to provide more space for larger pets to run around in. the issue with some of the other product here is that dogs can’t stray far from the transmitter without receiving a bit of a shock. This system runs to 1600ft and can be adapted with multiple collars as needed.
- A bigger area for dogs to play in
- Multiple collars as needed
- A pretty reliable signal
- Not enough settings for the static correction
- Mixed responses from the dogs
There are users that are impressed with the quality of the kit and the impact that it has on their dog. It is easy to set up and the signal is fairly reliable. There are some that would like to see more settings for the intensity of the static for tougher or more stubborn dogs. Other than that, this seems to be a good system that offers the basics at a decent price.
This system sounds as though it should have everything that users need to create the perfect boundary for their pet. There is the wireless transmitter, a collar with an adjustable strap and a series of static signals and beeps for correction. There is also meant to be a test light, a selection of metal contact probes and the boundary flags.
- A long range when it works
- A pretty comprehensive kit
- A good range of correction options
- Some inconsistencies in the signals
- Needs better flags
The first issue here is that the boundary flags are not the big white ones that are so helpful and used by the top brands. Also, while there is a good range of 1000 feet as a maximum distance from the transmitter, there are many comments about inconsistencies. Some dogs are corrected far too early and the distance seems to jump around. This means further confusion for the animal and hassle for the owner. Therefore, this system isn’t worth your time and effort in the same way as other wireless models. The ideas are good, but the execution isn’t.
Hybrid pet containment systems for your home
This looks like a more refined and advances system compared to some of the in-ground options in this guide. Many of the features remain the same, there is 500ft of wire, a collar, a transmitter, some training flags and a correction method with tones and static.
- Plenty of wire for a good perimeter
- Progressive correction
- nice design to the receiver
- Inconsistencies with the signal
- Not as high-tech as some had hoped
Again, the collar can gradually increase the warnings as needed to offer more effective correction for the animal. There are some nice elements to the design, such as the slimmer receiver, the connectivity to the radio mat pet deterrent transmitter pad and the quality of the wire. Some have struggled with the installation process and set up due to a lack of instructions. There are also some people that have experienced issues with the range and inconsistencies with the signal. Some are more disappointed with this because they assumed they would get a lot more from this high-tech product.
This wireless system has an expandable range up to 0.55 acres. It provides a small static or audible correction to help dogs with their training. This is an updated model with a new waterproof collar. Another interesting thing about this model is that it doesn’t create the typical boundary you would expect there are double zones, double loops and the option of zones within zones.
- A decent range for small yards
- Different boundary shapes
- A new design to the collars
- The new collars are a bit flimsy
- Some signal issues
The collar is actually a lot more attractive than those seen in other product. It is easy to adjust for animals of different sizes and has different correction settings. The boundary options are also great for adding a little diversity to the system.
Unfortunately, there has been some issue with temperamental signals to the collars and some feel that this new design is a little too flimsy – as is the wire installed in the ground. So, there is still some room for improvement.
There are some interesting ideas in the correction system of this product. The transmitter uses what is called proportional stimuli to adjust the response to the pet’s distance from the perimeter. This starts out as a warning and builds if pets continue to walk toward the wire. The signal goes to a waterproof, rechargeable collar.
- A decent range on the transmitter
- Proportional stimuli
- Waterproof collar
- Correction when the dog isn’t near the boundary
- Some installation issues
There are some nice details to this kit. There is a signal field of 27,000 square feet and indicators on the transmitter in case animals break the perimeter. However, there are also some problems with the system. Some experienced signal issues where the collar would go off at the wrong time. This even happened when the dog was lying down in the home. Others couldn’t get the wire to connect to the transmitter at all. This means some serious trust issues on both sides.
This is another system that brings together lots of great elements from different systems to create a product with a lot of potential. There is the same approach with the proportional static shock to give dogs more of a warning if they are about to step into the wrong part of the yard. There is also a speed detection system that should help to eliminate the problem of dogs running through the barrier.
- Speed detection system
- Proportional correction system
- Alerts when there are problems
- Mixed results
- Not the best training flags
Then there are the additional sensitivity settings and the ability to get alerts when the boundary has been broken. There is a lot here that could be of benefit in the right garden. Results are mixed, with some people saying that it doesn’t affect their animal. But, most are happy with the product and features. Some improved training flags might help further for new users.
Like some of the other smarter systems in this guide, this fence system allows for lots of different configurations so that users can create the right type of boundary for their animals. This means single and double loops, zones with zones and other barriers. Ideally, pet owners should be able to customise the set-up to the needs of the dog as well as the configuration of the land.
- Customisation for different loops
- Multiple collars if required
- Waterproof receiver
- Inconsistencies with the signal
- Flimsy components
There is a 200m wire for a smaller yard, a waterproof collar with static correction and the chance to use multiple collars as needed. The premise of this system is pretty good. The design of the perimeter and the controls on the receiver should allow for a good experience. The problem is that many users have struggled with inconsistent signals and the build quality of the components.
Finally, let’s look at some of the most basic in-ground dog fences that are available as an alternative to the wireless models seen so far.
This in-ground system users 500 feet of perimeter wire to help users create the ideal boundary of any size around their home. There are 2 adjustable zones on the transmitter and a fully waterproof collar to pick up the signal. This collar uses 8 levels of static to control the dog.
- Plenty of wire for a good boundary
- A good amount of correction settings
- Lots of flags and points in the kit
- Issues with the distance from the wire
- Short-term lifespan
One of the main benefits of this system is the amount of kit that you get in the box. There is a battery pack designed to last for 6 months, 50 training flags to help dogs understand their boundaries and two different set of contact points for the collar – this includes a long one for long coated breeds. The downsides hers are that it begins to beep from quite a distance away from the wire. This means that some dogs may not have far to go in a small yard. Others have struggled with the system dying after a short period.
This is another simple in-ground kit from a brand that we know very well. PetSafe is one of the leading companies around. So, if you want to switch to an in-ground option after trying wireless, this could be a good place to start. The kit contains enough wire for 1/3 of an acre of coverage, an adjustable collar, 4 levels of static correction for training and some training flags. Users can expand the system with more wire and flags for a higher price.
- Plenty of coverage for larger yards
- The kit is expandable as needed
- Some quick results with the right dog
- Some reports of weaknesses in the connections and wire
- Not ideal for larger dogs
There have been some complaints about weak points in the wire and an unreliable connection from the transmitter. However, there are also plenty of users that have seen results. Many will stress that the impact of these fences often depends on the dog as much as the installation process. There have also been cases where the collar come loose on larger dogs.
As the name suggests, this product is best suited to smaller animals. The collar is smaller with adjustments between 6 and 26 inches. The collar may be smaller and the demographic more niche, but there is still the same full kit on offer. Users get the transmitter, wire, training flags and even an instructional training DVD. This all means that this should be easy to use for those with minimal experience.
- Ideal for smaller dogs
- A good kit with plenty of items
- An additional instructional DVD
- Stubborn dogs breaking through
- Some quality control issues
There is also the benefit that this system has 4 levels of correction, including a tone-only mode for training. However, there are some buyers that question the worth of this product for all breeds. There are many comments about tough, stubborn dogs ignoring the static because it simply wasn’t strong enough to deter them from their quest to break the boundary. There are also some issues with the durability of the prongs.
This final model is one that also appears to have just enough in the box to keep dog owners happy. There is 65ft of wire, which should be enough to create a decent perimeter around the yard, there are 20 training flags to use to mark out the boundary and aid with training. There are also two weatherproof collars with extra contact points and the wall mounted transmitter.
- Two collars in the box rather than one
- Plenty of flags and points
- Some great results from the correction system
- A lack of power to the wire and receiver
- Not the most durable collar
Many are happy with the response of the collar and the way that it aids with training. The installation process was also easier than some imagined. However, there are those that say that there isn’t enough power to the wire or the receiver and that the collars are a bit too flimsy for long term use.
Why are wireless dog fences so popular with pet owners?
The first question that you might ask here is simple. Why buy one of these electric dog fences when you can put up a physical boundary instead. There are a couple of issues to consider here. The first is the fact that it may not be practical to do so. Homeowner regulations and property plans may mean that you cant secure the entire perimeter. Also, neighbours may not be too keen on you building massive fences adjacent to their own property. Then there is the fact that a physical fence may be no match for your pet. They may be able to dig underneath or jump over it – depending on their physical strength, agility and determination.
This is why so many dog owners turn to these invisible electric dog fences. These systems mean that you can create a boundary that makes no difference to the neighbours, and should be escape-proof. The idea is simple. You set up a boundary – either with a central transmitter or an in-ground wire – and place a receiver on the collar of the dog. When the dog gets too close to the boundary they will receive correction in the form of static, vibration or a sound. With time, they will learn not to pass beyond that point.
Benefits of having wireless dog fence
Another common question is whether or not it is really worth the time and money to install these systems on your property. Again, we have to remember that there are pros and cons to both in ground dog fence products and above ground wireless electric dog fences. The main benefits here are as follows.
- Ease of use
- Simple correction systems
- Great results
These wireless above ground solutions are easy to set up and modify as needed. This means that, where possible, you can extend the range or relocate the transmitter. There is no need for hard landscaping to install wires and create precision layouts. The approach may be more simplistic, but it can offer the same results when used correctly. With the right range and correction signal, your pets can learn their boundaries. With time, they won’t need the collar at all. The added benefit here with these wireless models is that you can always re-use it if you ever get a new puppy.
Whatever product you choose when looking for the best electric dog fence, don’t forget about the importance of training.
Your dog may be a smart breed, but they aren’t going to learn all this by themselves. Successful boundary training in a minimal amount of time requires the right training. They need to understand why their new collar makes those sounds or vibrations when they stray too far. They need to understand where that boundary is. They also need to be introduced to the concepts gradually to avoid stress. The worst thing that you can do here is set up a new fence, turn the collar to a high setting and let the dog loose. They will be confused by all the changes and scared of the results. Work with them in gradual steps.
- Let your dog get used to the collar before you turn on the fence. There are lots of different things for dogs to get used to in this training programme. don’t give them too much to handle at once. Let them wear the collar and get used to it for a few days.
- After a few days with the collar on, you can put them on the leash and walk them around the perimeter of the new boundary. Make sure to set out all the boundary flags and let the dog have a good sniff. Continue this for a few days to the dog begins to learn their limits in the yard.
- Then you can activate the fence and the collar. Walk them round again and let them see what happens when they get close to the boundary zone. Don’t do this for too long. Limit the time they spend wearing the collar to avoid discomfort or distress.
- Show them the safe way out. There is one entrance/exit to the property that acts as an invisible gate. This is where they can leave with you, on the leash, with no correction. Guide them through this area so they know the difference between the safe point and the boundaries.
- Let them off the leash with the collar activated so they can use the yard as normal. They need to be able to act like a normal dog and prove that they understand what they were taught. Even so, you need to make sure that they are monitored at all times, just in case there is a fault with the system or the dog gets upset.
In short, it is possible to help your dog respect their boundaries with the right training and the best electric dog fence.
The products that we have listed here today showcase some of the best features that are available in top rated dog containment systems. The in-ground dog fences are a little time consuming, but the best have strong, long wires for vast areas. They also offer great connections to one or multiple collars. The wireless dog fences don’t have the same range or consistency, but they do have a simple installation process and are easy to use. They too have some great adjustable, waterproof collars with different correction modes.
The best wireless dog fences don’t have to be a cause for concern or stress. There are some terrible products out there that give the market a bad name, all because of their intense shocks or unreliable boundaries. However, there are also many more that are safe and effective thanks to their connections and options. If you are prepared to put in the work and train your dogs well, you should find that you can teach them to respect their boundaries in no time.
Dawn Bradley is a content writer, blogger and animal lover. She is also a pet parent. She has written many reviews and guides aimed at helping our four-legged friends and, in turn, their two legged owners. She also runs a nature blog about her home town of Plymouth, UK.